What’s wrong with Plesk

Increasingly I'm growing disillusioned with Plesk and SWsoft the company behind it. For me it is a stagnant product and a lack of competition is the root cause.

The good part

Plesk is an amazing tool. It allows non-technical users to administer a server without any technical knowledge and without ever opening the command line. As a product it has allowed thousands, probably tens of thousands to administer servers without needing to use the command line or understanding how servers work. This is a good thing. Technology should allow people to use things without understanding them and Plesk is a primary example of that.

My history with Plesk

I started using Plesk two years ago and loved the ease of use it gave me. I was able to set up sites, subdomains, email addresses without really understanding what was going on. For a license fee I was able to cut out the requirement to pay someone to administer my server, or for me to learn basic Linux administration. The software worked and I was confident that I could offer clients a high end service. Indeed I did.

What's wrong then?

For me Plesk is a stagnant product that can afford to remain as it is because it has no real competition. CPanel is the only other major player in the market. Why do I use the word stagnant? I use it because on Plesk Linux there is still no out-of-the-box for PHP5, a product that has been out for over three years. It still offers PHP4, a product that is due to stop being supported by PHP at the end of 2007. This is a staggering situation for a paid-for enterprise level piece of software. There would seem to be no plans to address this at all.

But we want stable software!

I accept the argument that hosts want stable software. They want to offer clients a solid piece of kit that they can rely on and that they won't have to support as much. I often feel sorry for my hosts Media Temple that they have no choice other than to offer an outdated solution that with each release they have to delay installing because of bug list after bug list. It is not their fault. This is Media Temple, a cutting edge host offering dedicated hosting with PHP4 and MySQL4! Users are crying out for an upgrade, doing it themselves or moaning at (mt). Do they have an alternative. No. Plesk has so little competition it doesn't really have to try.

Help is at hand

Thankfully for the community help is at hand in the form of Scott Shinn, a founder of Plesk. He seems to be doing most of the work that the other Plesk developers should be doing even though his resume says he doesn't work there any more. At Atomic Turtle he maintains repositories for the product that users can use to update and maintain their installation. What does this need though? The Command Line! Why don't SWsoft offer the same dedication to their product?

Leaving Plesk?

Over the last two years I have learnt more about Linux administration and now feel comfortable with administering a Linux server via the command line. Using Plesk it actually takes longer to do things than it would with the command line. That's an aside though. For me the product is way out of date and requires the command line to bring it up to date, negating the very thing it was meant to do. Why should I fix a product that offers software that won't be supported by the end of this month? There is no real alternative and cutting edge hosts like Media Temple are offering a package that is way way out of date. At the end of this month it will be software that is not even supported. Sorry SWsoft - it is not good enough.

Comments

Chris Coyier Dec 5 2007

I was quite glad the day I left Plesk forever. I have since moved all my hosting to a combination of TextDrive and Media Temple servers which both use their own proprietary administration panels.

TextDrive’s is actually pretty similarly bad, but it’s so much simpler that it’s not so bar really.

Media Temple is just plain awesome. Very well designed, simple to use, makes sense. I’m not sure what you mean by out of date… but I just have a fairly basic plan, not a dedicate server which might use something different.

George Ornbo Dec 5 2007

@Chris Coyer - I think you must be on the (gs) plan which does allow you to use PHP5 and has a custom control panel.

What I mean is that for the (dv) you get Plesk with PHP4. There is no PHP5 support out-of-the-box. Given that PHP4 is not going to be supported at the end of this year I would have thought this would be high priority for SWsoft but seemingly not..

I’m also really happy with (mt). They don’t really have any say over Plesk but it is seems odd to me that the shared plans are a higher spec and more usable than the dedicated ones. If I was (mt) I’d be looking for another product.

Alex @ (mt) Dec 12 2007

centos 5 / php 5 / mysql 5 is coming very soon to (mt)’s (dv) line.

As for Plesk, my hope is we’ll see some interesting things come out of SWsoft soon. Virtuozzo 4 is coming along nicely.

That’s about all I can say here but drop me an email as I’d love to pass along feedback to SWsoft.

Cheers.

Guy Feb 13 2008

How does PLESK compare to Joomla?

George Ornbo Feb 14 2008

@Guy - PLESK is a tool for managing a Linux server via a graphical user interface. Joomla is a Content Management System so they are totally different I think!

Linux Forums Feb 18 2008